For displaced, misplaced, and nostalgic ex-Brooklynites

Re: Flatbush


[ Responses ] [ Post Response ] [ Nostalgia Message Board ] [ Brooklyn Board Home ]

Posted by Matty from Flatbush on Friday, July 24th 2020:

In Reply to: Flatbush posted by Will Suphan on Thursday, July 23rd 2020:

There's actually a set of rules for this. To sum it up either Flatbusher or Flatbushite is good. Found this online:


7 Rules for Identifying People by Place Names
By Mark Nichol

George R. Stewart, if he is remembered today at all, is noted as the writer of Earth Abides, a seminal work in the science fiction subgenre of the postapocalyptic novel. But to some language geeks he is hailed as an onomastician, a scholar of place names. Stewart, in the 1930s, is perhaps best known in the latter role for proposing a schema for how to identify someone according to their place of origin or residence.

Journalist and scholar H.L. Mencken was reportedly so impressed with the following distillation that he named them Stewart’s Laws of Municipal Onomastics:

1. Add -n to a place name ending in -a or -ia (Atlantan, Californian).

2. Add -an to a place name ending in -i or sounding like -e (Hawaiian, Baltimorean).

3. Add -ian to a place name ending in -on (Washingtonian).

4. Change -y to -i and add -an to a place name ending in -y (Schenectadian).

5. Add -an to a place name ending in -o (Ohioan).

6. Add -ite or -er to a place name ending in a consonant or a silent -e (New Englander, Seattleite).

7. Delete -s and add -tan to a place name ending in -polis (Annapolitan, for Annapolis).

That’s an impressive and helpful set of rules. Unfortunately, many people didn’t get the memo, so we find the rules widely broken. For example, someone from Florida is a Floridian, not a Floridan, and one writes of San Franciscans, not San Franciscoans. Parisians breaks the rules (it should be Parisite — ouch — or Pariser), as does Chinese (Stewart’s rule dictates Chinan).

Then there are classical affectations like Cantabrigian (Cambridge), Novocastrian (Newcastle, in Australia), and Oxonian (Oxford); more or less well-known foreign language alterations such as Flemish (Flanders), Madrileno (Madrid), and Muscovite (Moscow); and references — some famous, others obscure — based on state nicknames, think “Bay Stater” (Massachusetts), Hoosier (Indiana), and Nutmegger (Connecticut).

Thus, like many other attempts at codifying human behavior or custom, Stewart’s laws are breached as often as they are observed, but they’re still a useful guideline. Ultimately, though, let your fingers do the walking through a dictionary, geographical dictionary, atlas, or other resource.

Reference ID: BK96419



Responses:



Post a Response

Your Name:
Your E-Mail:
Password:
Alternative E-Mail:
Email Address in Post?Show original     Show alternative     Show no email address
Subject:Re: Flatbush
Message:

Non-supporters are limited to 2 messages per 24-hour period. If you'd like to become a Brooklyn Board supporter and have unlimited access, click here.
By clicking on "Post This Message", you agree to abide by the Message Content Guidelines.

You must be registered to post your response.

   


[ Responses ] [ Post Response ] [ Nostalgia Message Board ] [ Brooklyn Board Home ]